ChildsWork News, April 18, 2012: Reading Methods and 504 Plans in Private Schools
Good morning! As we hit midweek I have found two really interesting articles that discuss some important educational ideas familiar to us all here at CW. The first is a really exciting study which has found that the way in which teachers (and parents) approach reading aloud to young children – preschoolers, mainly – can affect their reading skills as they continue through school. The study was conducted by researchers at Ohio State University and is certainly worth considering for all people who read to young children. How can you change your reading routine to reflect these new suggestions? Do you agree with their value? The next article comes from a familiar place – Education Week’s On Special Education blogger Nirvi Shah. She reports on parents who are suing the Baltimore School District for services for their child, who has ADHD and an anxiety disorder. Though the child attends private school, the parents feel that the 504 services that their child qualifies for should still be provided. Though the parents were initially defeated in court and denied their appeal at the U.S. District Court, they are now slated to be heard by the 4th District Court of Appeals. Unlike school voucher programs, 504 students do not receive federal aid at the district level, so the issue about how much funding should be reserved for these children, especially those attending private schools, is a huge debate among administrators, parents, and over-taxed constituents. This is not a cut and dry issue. What are your feelings? Preschoolers’ Reading Skills Benefit from One Modest Change by Teachers From Ohio State University A small change in how teachers and parents read aloud to preschoolers may provide a big boost to their reading skills later on, a new study found. That small change involves making specific references to print in books while reading to children – such as pointing out letters and words on the pages, showing capital letters, and showing how you read from left to right and top to bottom on the page. Preschool children whose teachers used print references during storybook reading showed more advanced reading skills one and even two years later when compared to children whose teachers did not use such references. This is the first study to show causal links between referencing print and later literacy achievement. “Using print references during reading was just a slight tweak to what teachers were already doing in the classroom, but it led to a sizeable improvement in reading for kids,” said Shayne Piasta, co-author of the study and assistant professor of teaching and learning at Ohio State University. “This would be a very manageable change for most preschool teachers, who already are doing storybook reading in class.” Piasta conducted the study with lead investigator Laura Justice, professor of teaching and learning at Ohio State, as well as co-investigators Anita McGinty of the University of Virginia and Joan Kaderavek of the University of Toledo. Their results appear in the April 2012 issue of the journal Child Development. The study is part of Project STAR (Sit Together And Read), a randomized clinical trial based at Ohio State to test the short- and long-term impacts associated with reading regularly to preschool children in the classroom. The study involved more than 300 children in 85 classrooms who participated in a 30-week shared reading program. As a group, the children came from low-income homes, started with below-average language skills and were at substantial risk for later reading difficulties. The children were separated into three groups: high-dose STAR (four reading sessions per week), low-dose STAR (two reading sessions per week) and a third comparison group who also had four reading sessions per week. All teachers in the three groups read the same 30 books to their students. Teachers in the two STAR groups were trained to make specific print references while reading the books. Teachers in the comparison group were told to read as they normally would, and were not prompted to make print references. Results showed that both one and even two years later, preschoolers in the high-dose STAR classrooms had higher word reading, spelling and comprehension skills than did children in the comparison group. The benefits were not as clear for those in the low-dose STAR classrooms, although they did seem to have slightly better skills than those children in the comparison classrooms. Piasta said it was particularly notable that students in the high-dose STAR classrooms scored higher on tests of reading comprehension. “If you’re getting kids to pay attention to letters and words, it makes sense that they will do better at word recognition and spelling,” she said. “But the fact that they also did better at understanding the passages they read is really exciting. That suggests this intervention may help them become better readers.” How do print references help preschoolers become better readers? Piasta said research suggests it helps children learn the code of letters and how they relate to words and to meaning. “By showing them what a letter is and what a letter means, and what a word is and what a word means, we’re helping them to crack the code of language and understand how to read,” she said. While this study shows the value of using print references with preschoolers, research suggests very few teachers and parents do this systematically, according to Piasta. An earlier study by Justice and her colleagues showed that untrained teachers reference print about 8.5 times per reading session – compared to up to 36 times for those who were trained. Parents are even less likely to make print references while reading to their children. One study suggests that parents use such references only about once during a typical 10-minute reading session. “One of the best things about the power of print referencing is how easy it would be to implement during shared reading in the classroom,” Piasta said. “Compared to a lot of interventions, this only requires a small adjustment to teachers’ typical reading style. But it pays large dividends in reading skills.” This research was supported by a grant from the Institute of Education Sciences, part of the U.S. Department of Education. Are Children at Private Schools Entitled to Services Under Section 504? By Nirvi Shah The parents of a student in Baltimore have sued the school district for not providing services under Section 504 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973. The parents of student D.L., who has ADHD and an anxiety disorder, enrolled their child in a private school several years ago. Then they requested an evaluation from the school district to see if their child was eligible for special education services. Eventually, their lawsuit says, the city of Baltimore school district evaluated D.L. and found that he was eligible for 504 services, but not while attending a private school. When the parents filed an official complaint, the hearing officer agreed that D.L. couldn't get 504 services even if he or she was enrolled at both the private school and a public school. He had to be enrolled at a public school full time. That led to a lawsuit in 2010. A U.S. District Court in Maryland upheld the school district's decision.